Kinnelon NJ Housing Update November 2025

If you’re wondering how the real estate market is performing in Kinnelon, NJ, you’re not alone. As someone who grew up in Kinnelon, lives in Kinnelon, and owns Blue Flags Realty right here in town, I’m passionate about keeping my neighbors informed and empowered. Here’s your 2025 update, directly from a local expert Kurt Wubbenhorst.

How’s the Kinnelon Real Estate Market in 2025?

Kinnelon’s market has been nothing short of dynamic this year. The average home value in Kinnelon is around $832,552, representing a 3.4% increase over the past twelve months. Some recent data even shows median sale prices reaching as high as $920,000—up 20.7% year-over-year—with homes selling in about 85 days on average. Sellers are still enjoying solid negotiating strength, but homes are taking a bit longer to move than in the red-hot days of 2022–2023.

For those selling, Kinnelon remains very much a seller’s market: the average home is still selling for roughly 4% over list price, and especially desirable properties can go for as much as 11% over in just about two weeks. Buyers, on the other hand, are benefitting from a slightly expanding inventory, which offers more choices and better opportunities to negotiate—especially on homes that are priced above neighborhood averages.

Why Trust a Kinnelon Local?

As the owner of Blue Flags Realty, I know these neighborhoods inside and out—not just from a professional perspective, but because Kinnelon has always been home. I’ve watched our area’s schools, lakes, and community spirit attract families looking for both tranquility and top-tier amenities. My deep roots in Kinnelon allow me to provide insights that go beyond the numbers: I know which streets are best for trick-or-treating, where to find the best local pizza, and which homes offer you the best backyard sunsets.

What’s Next for Buyers and Sellers in Kinnelon?

If you’re thinking about listing, pricing your home strategically remains key to attracting fast, competitive offers. Condition and curb appeal matter more than ever, even as buyers seek more selection. For buyers, there’s no need to wait for a “crash” that’s not coming—smart, informed shoppers with local guidance are securing great properties, often with favorable terms.

Ready to make your move? Let’s navigate the Kinnelon real estate market together! Contact me, Kurt Wubbenhorst at Blue Flags Realty—your neighbor, your advocate, and your trusted Kinnelon real estate expert.

Kinnelon Quick Stats (2025):

• Average home value: $832,552 (+3.4% YoY)
  
  
• Median sale price: $920,000 (+20.7% YoY)
  
  
• Typical days on market: 71–85 days
  
  
• Seller’s market, but with more options for buyers than recent years
  
  

When it comes to Kinnelon, trust a local who truly calls it home.